In his latest column, Rev Ian Miller discusses the controversial concept of working together in politics - and asks 'Why must there always be contention and distrust?'

Recently, I listened to a bassoon quartet playing together at Ross Priory.

I had never figured that four bassoons could make such music but they did.

For me, the bassoon was a strange instrument that made odd noises in the orchestra but this group produced music of the highest calibre.

What intrigued me was the way they interacted with each other. I was sitting a few feet away from them and watched the glances and the nods and realised they had established such an affinity that the end result was perfect harmony.

As I watched I thought would it not be great if our governments, local and national, would find a similar closeness? Everyone working together, singing from the same hymn sheet just like them.

Why must there always be contention and distrust? Surely, no matter how much you disagree with opposing political thought, now and again your political opponents must come up with something worth applauding - but it never happens does it?

If you are on the blue side the red side must always be in the wrong and vice versa.

I also cannot understand the furore that is often caused when some politician does not toe the party line. They are then immediately suspended from the party. Loyalty is all important.

It seems they are no longer allowed to exercise their own judgement and call it as they see it. Following the party line is all important and you must do it even when you believe, in all conscience, that line to be wrong.

I guess I am naïve. I would never have made a good politician but for me the loyalty of any politician local or otherwise should always be first and foremost to the patch they represent.

I am told that for effective government that would not work and that I am just a mistaken idealist.

I believe the concept of the Scottish Parliament with proportional representation was intended to force politicians to work together.

They would have to co-operate in a consensual way to solve problems which affect us all.

But instead divisiveness and petty name calling still rules. In fairness, Westminster is even worse with MPs, acting at times like kids out of St Trinian's.

However, when I look across the pond and consider the forthcoming presidential election all I can say is that I am glad I am not an American... it’s a small consolation.